Template · 9 min read

Brand audit template: a step-by-step scorecard

By the Red Balloon team · Updated · Part of Brand audit

A brand audit template gives you a repeatable way to check how your brand actually shows up, compared with how you think it does. The template below has five parts: a touchpoint inventory, perception research, a competitor comparison, a scoring rubric and a set of risk checks, ending in a ranked action plan.

You can run it yourself with a spreadsheet, a few customer calls and access to your analytics. It works for a single-location business in India or a company selling abroad; only the number of markets and competitors changes.

Copy each table into a sheet, fill it in, and score every row against the same rubric so you can rerun the audit later and see what improved.

When a brand audit is worth doing

Audits are most useful just before a big decision, so the findings shape the spend rather than justify it afterwards. If none of the triggers below applies, a lighter yearly check of your touchpoints and reviews may be enough. If two or more apply, run the full template.

  • You are about to rebrand, redesign the website or launch a large campaign.
  • The business has grown through several agencies, acquisitions or product lines, and logos, tones and claims no longer match.
  • Sales says prospects confuse you with a competitor, or ask for discounts because they can't see the difference.
  • Ratings or review sentiment have slipped, and nobody is sure why.
  • You are entering a new city, segment or country and need to know what travels.
  • Leadership disagrees about what the brand stands for.

The audit is a diagnosis, not a redesign. Its job is to tell you what to keep, what to fix and what to retire, ranked by commercial impact. If the findings point to deeper problems with what you stand for, they feed into positioning strategy work next.

The brand audit template at a glance

The five parts below build on each other. The inventory shows what exists, perception research shows how it lands, the competitor grid shows the context, the scorecard turns it all into numbers you can compare, and the risk checks catch legal and compliance gaps before they become expensive.

PartWhat you collectOutput
1. Touchpoint inventoryEvery place customers meet the brand, with screenshots and ownersA full asset list with consistency flags
2. Perception researchCustomer and lost-prospect interviews, reviews, short surveysThemes: what people value, what confuses them
3. Competitor comparisonTwo to five rivals' claims, visuals, pricing pages and reviewsWhere you are distinct and where you blend in
4. ScorecardScores on six dimensions against a written rubricA red, amber or green view by dimension
5. Risk checksTrademarks, claims, licences, consent for research dataA risk list for legal review
Action planFindings ranked by impact and effortA dated plan with owners

Agree the scope before you start: which brands or sub-brands, which markets and which competitors. A tight scope finished properly beats a broad one abandoned halfway. The owner page for our brand audit services shows how we phase the same steps.

Part 1: the touchpoint inventory

List every place a customer, partner or recruit meets your brand, then capture what each one looks like today. Include the boring ones; sales decks, WhatsApp templates and invoices are often the most off-brand, because teams edit them without design review. Use this template for each row.

TouchpointOwnerLast updatedMatches current guidelines?Message usedFix needed
Website home and key pagesMarketingYes, partly or noHeadline and main claim
Google Business Profiles and listingsBranch managersName, category, description
Social profiles and recent postsSocial teamBio and pinned post
Ads running nowPerformance teamMain promise
Sales deck and proposalsSalesOpening slide claim
Packaging, signage and printOperations
Email and WhatsApp templatesCRM owner
Invoices, forms and onboardingFinance and support
Careers page and job adsHR

Screenshot everything into one folder with the date, and note the main claim each touchpoint makes. Laying the claims side by side is often the most revealing step of the whole audit: many companies discover they make five different promises depending on who wrote the page.

Part 2: perception research

Your own view of the brand is the least reliable input. Talk to customers, including people who chose a competitor, and mine what they already say in public. Five to ten conversations usually surface the main themes; stop when new calls stop adding new points. Record calls only with consent.

Interview guide

  1. What were you trying to solve when you started looking for a provider like us?
  2. Which other options did you consider, including doing nothing or doing it in-house?
  3. What made you choose us, or choose someone else?
  4. How would you describe us to a colleague in one sentence?
  5. What nearly stopped you from buying?
  6. What has been better or worse than you expected since?
  7. If we disappeared tomorrow, what would you use instead?

Review and mention mining

Export reviews from Google, marketplaces, app stores or sector platforms, and tag each one by theme: product, price, service, delivery, staff, trust. One-star themes show where the promise and the experience part ways. Five-star themes show what people value enough to mention unprompted, which is often different from what your advertising says.

Part 3: the competitor comparison grid

Choose rivals from lost deals and from the companies that appear for your main search terms, not from the brands leadership admires. Then fill the grid with what each one says and shows publicly. The aim is to find where you sound identical and where you have room to stand apart. Our brand positioning examples from India show what clearly distinct positions look like.

DimensionYour brandRival ARival BRival C
Main claim on the homepage
Target customer, as stated or implied
Price position and how pricing is shown
Proof offered: certifications, case studies, data
Visual style: colours, photography, tone
Review rating and top complaint theme
Branded search interest, from Google Trends
What AI assistants say when asked about the category

Live ads are a quick source for the claims row. Meta's Ad Library and Google's Ads Transparency Center both show competitors' current adverts, which tell you what they are emphasising right now. For international markets, repeat the grid with the rivals buyers in that country actually consider.

Part 4: the scoring rubric

Score each dimension from 1 to 5 using written criteria, so two people scoring separately reach similar results and the audit can be repeated. Have two people score independently and discuss any gap of more than one point. Treat 1 and 2 as red, 3 as amber, and 4 and 5 as green.

DimensionScore 1Score 3Score 5
Message clarityNo consistent claim; each touchpoint says something differentA main claim exists but is diluted or buriedOne clear claim, used consistently and understood by customers
Visual consistencySeveral logos, colours and styles in useCore assets consistent; older materials off-brandEvery audited touchpoint on current guidelines
DifferentiationIndistinguishable from rivals in the gridSome distinct elements but a shared core claimA position no rival claims, backed by proof
Customer perceptionReviews and interviews contradict the brand promiseMixed; strengths and recurring complaintsCustomers describe you in words close to your intended position
FindabilityBrand searches show wrong, outdated or rival resultsOwned results present but incompleteAccurate owned results, profiles and AI answers
Claims and complianceUnsupported superlatives and unlicensed assetsSome claims lack evidence on fileEvery claim substantiated; licences and consents documented

Part 5: risk checks before you fix anything

Audits often uncover legal and compliance gaps that are cheap to fix now and expensive later. Run these checks and pass anything uncertain to a qualified lawyer; the audit flags risks, it does not give legal opinions. This section is general information, not legal advice.

CheckHow to run itWhy it matters
Trademark screeningSearch your name and logo on the Trade Mark Registry's public search in India, and on the national registry in each market abroadSimilar registered marks can force a costly rename
Claim substantiationList every claim such as best, first or number one, and the evidence on fileThe ASCI Code requires claims to be capable of substantiation, with sources for research-based claims
Font and image licencesCheck licences cover web, app, print and broadcast useDesktop font licences and agency-bought stock often don't transfer to you
Research data consentConfirm interviewees and survey respondents gave notice-based consentIndia's DPDP Rules were notified in November 2025 with an eighteen-month phased compliance period
Sector rulesCheck healthcare, finance, property or education claims against the regulator's rulesRegulated sectors limit testimonials and superiority claims

Turning findings into a ranked action plan

An audit that ends with a long list of issues rarely changes anything. Rank every finding by commercial impact and effort, give it an owner and a date, and do the high-impact, low-effort fixes first. Logos, listings and sales decks are usually quick wins; positioning and identity changes take longer.

FindingImpact (high, medium, low)Effort (high, medium, low)OwnerDue dateMetric to watch
Example: three logo versions in use across branchesMediumLowMarketingTouchpoints on current guidelines
Example: homepage claim matches two rivals word for wordHighMediumFounder and marketingHomepage-to-enquiry conversion
Example: unanswered negative reviews on two profilesHighLowBranch managersReview reply rate

Rerun the scorecard six to twelve months later with the same rubric and competitor set, so you can show what moved. If you would rather not run the audit alone, our brand audit page explains how we do it. In the Growth Audit, a two-week paid diagnostic, we build a brand health scorecard with you using this structure, with the fee credited to the engagement that follows. Identity fixes can then move to our brand identity team.

FAQ

Questions people also ask

Straight answers from the practice lead. Highlighted text marks Red Balloon figures we confirm before publishing.

What is included in a brand audit?

A full brand audit usually covers an inventory of every customer touchpoint, research into how customers and lost prospects see the brand, a comparison with two to five competitors, a scored assessment of clarity, consistency, differentiation, perception, findability and compliance, and a ranked action plan. Some audits also screen trademarks and check that marketing claims can be substantiated.

    How long does a brand audit take?

    It depends on the number of touchpoints, markets and competitors in scope, and how quickly you can arrange customer interviews, which is usually the slowest step. A single brand in one market moves much faster than a group with several sub-brands across countries. We agree the duration once the scope is set.

      Can I do a brand audit myself?

      Yes. The template above is designed for in-house use with a spreadsheet, analytics access and a handful of customer calls. The main risks are bias and blind spots: teams tend to score their own work kindly and avoid talking to lost customers. Having two people score independently, or bringing in an outside reviewer, reduces both.

        How often should a company audit its brand?

        A light check of touchpoints and reviews once a year keeps drift under control. Run the full audit before a rebrand, a major campaign, a new market entry or after an acquisition, and whenever sales or reviews suggest customers are confused about what you stand for. Using the same rubric each time lets you compare results.

          What is the difference between a brand audit and a marketing audit?

          A brand audit asks whether your identity, message and reputation are clear, consistent and distinct. A marketing audit asks whether your channels, campaigns, tracking and spend are producing leads and sales efficiently. They overlap on messaging and reviews, and many businesses run both, starting with the brand audit when the problem looks like confusion rather than cost.

            Sources checked for this guide (3)
            1. ASCI: The ASCI Code
            2. Trade Mark Registry, India: Trade Mark Public Search
            3. PIB: Government notifies DPDP Rules to empower citizens and protect privacy

            Platform prices and rules change. We recheck these sources when we update the guide; confirm anything critical with the source before you act on it.

            Start with an audit

            Ready for
            lift?

            A paid two-week Growth Audit covers your funnel, ads, site, tracking and automation gaps, and ends with a 90-day plan you can run with or without us. The fee is credited against your next engagement.

            Prefer to talk? Call +91 97114 48083, or email info@redballoon.in.

            A person from the team replies to every enquiry.

            What do you need?
            Your details are sent over a secure, encrypted connection and only used to reply to you.